idw.community

6 5

I stumbled on the following question:

Human beings are immensely imperfect with many potentialities unrealised. Are they failure of design or are they failure of evolution?

It is a philosophical question, no? Are there any philosophers out there?

Naomi 8 Nov 8
Share

Be part of the movement!

Welcome to the community for those who value free speech, evidence and civil discourse.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

It's a paradox, humans are perfect in their imperfections. Life is growth, like music is multiple notes, it's beauty is in the change but we are always trying to hold on to this idea of a constant. To assume humans are a failure or a design flaw is to assume what we are judging is a complete picture. Our perspective and our assessment of how it makes us feel is all this question really asks, and the answers to those questions are very limited by our own ignorance.

You are alive, its not a failure. Perfect is a feeling we came up with, life is perfect, it's just not perfect to us.
"Normalcy is an illusion, what is normal to the spider is chaos to the fly."
Do you feel the divine nature of the universe when you see a spider making its web, or catching its meal?
The spider and the fly are perfect, people just like to argue about the nature of things when it effects them negatively.

I think this question highlights the imperfection in humanity as well as any answers in responses could.

1

I think of life here and now as a kindergarten in the evolution of spiritual life. We must learn what it is we need to learn to go on to the higher grades, university perhaps, some will go on to a "post doctorate" degree. Some will have to repeat grades before they understand what they need to further their journey to what we think of as perfection. Just say'n.

1

It's a modest and possibly innocent attempt. It's kinda cute though.

1

The question is based on an unsupported assumption, I don't agree that humans are a failure.
Against what criteria... can you describe a perfect being?
From a Christian perspective, as I understand it anyway; the whole point of this life is to establish an eternal, mutual relationship with God. Or... not.
Any relationship must be voluntary to be mutual. To hard-code a bunch of minions with a desire to hang out with you "designed-in", would ruin the whole point. They need the free will to either accept or reject the offer; to choose an option.
Options imply incompleteness; on-going development.
The notion of perfection implies completeness. Any variation on a perfect subject would necessarily be an imperfection. That leaves no room for growth or free will at all.
Ironically, that doesn't sound very perfect.

To ask whether human imperfection is the result of design or evolution, is really just to ask whether you believe in intelligent design... or evolution; which is another fallacy.
The two are not mutually exclusive. Evolution is a theoretical process, a mechanism. The theory itself does nothing to address the question of how that process was initiated.

Hello, and thank you for your input. I'll ponder on the question further.

2

It is just simply a way to ask whether a God could be the source of humanity, because he created an imperfect being. It to me, fails to rationally consider that if a perfect being created beings who were imperfect, there may be reasons we imperfect beings can't understand. A perfect being may create imperfections to achieve goals we have difficulty understanding.

Hello, and thank you for your comment. I'll ponder on the question further.

2

First the question is based on an assumption that does not necessarily have to be true, is not a fact, but a personal opinion of the person who posed the question. Why does it have to be a failure of any kind? We are spiritual creatures, made by a loving God. If anything "failures" come from not knowing and/or understanding God's will in our lives.

Hello. It is a theist-atheist question. Would be interesting to hear from atheists.

@Naomi from an atheist perspective, I think one would say that evolution is a process that works, and many creatures are successful enough to procreate and evolve.

Perfect and imperfect are irrelevant- it's all about passing along genes in combinations that survive.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:58129
IDW.community does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.