slug.com slug.com

12 9

Best languages for thinking?

A fair amount of theory suggests that we are limited in our thinking by the language we possess. I'm wondering if we were to start raising American children to be multi-lingual, which languages would give them the best second and third sets of thinking patterns. Would it offer a different set of ways to consider and solve problems?

govols 8 Apr 21
Share

Be part of the movement!

Welcome to the community for those who value free speech, evidence and civil discourse.

Create your free account

12 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

A problem is that the left is going around to 3rd world countries and pushing native language. This is proving to be detrimental to kids as they have enough of a hard time learning English which is proven to lead them out of poverty more than anything else. RElearning outdated language has no real positive results unless you are a hate whitie fanatic.

0

Very thought provoking, I would say to learn one language from each primary segment of the world, midland Europe, East Asian, Arabic and English, considering the mythology unique to each corner of the globe a visually oriented and imaginative child can use the connection between the imagery the words induce surrounding their origin to think more laterally. Maybe, I mean the ability to think laterally is important and I think the more tools at your disposal to see more images which make you draw more connections would undoubtedly lead to some quality insights. Just look at Carl Jung who knew Latin, English and German and the Mythology behind many cultures, I believe your idea is correct and holds alot of water, and I hope I was able to further it, thank you very much for posting it.

1

Learning a new language at a young age is ideal. Knowledge is power!!

0

French & Spanish

1

I listened to someone who claimed that his southern Italian dialect had no future tense and that limited the achievements of his culture.
I think German and English are great for technology but not so much for emotional life.
Gaelic has advantages for concept construction as it's a "remnant language" and children can comprehend complexity easier because the roots of the complex word are present in it. Also, unlike English, a person's identity isn't defined by their actions. You can't BE stupid and more than you can be a fire hydrant. Emotions or actions are (on) you as is your name. YOU are seperate. You can't call a kid "stupid".
I love the descriptive aspect of Yiddish.
French and Italian are fantastic for terms around art.

0

I think the movie "Arrival" was about this very idea. great movie btw...if you have not seen the movie be forewarned - it is very confusing at first because you don't know the movie jumps forward and backwards in time. I recommend watching it at least 2 times.

0

very interesting question

0

Good topic.

1

I've alway wanted to learn Japanese, started a few times but haven't been able to stick with it. I've heard it's a beautiful language in its complexity.

If you haven't seen it I recommend watching the movie Arival, it's a Syfy all about the alien language and how it changes the way your brain works as you understand it.

I've had a similar effect myself as I learn to communicate better with my body. it's really been opening my mind in a way I wasn't expecting, I've even used the consepts from that movie to try explaining it to people.

I think your onto something here, and it doesnt help that at large we have been dumbing down the English language over the years.

5

Any language is fine for thinking. For communication it is best to have a full understanding of one language and not a fair understanding of a few languages. Used to be that the reason we still learned Latin was that it was the universal base of all languages of western society. It was adopted by the scientific community.

1

Words are essentially sounds that have concepts so in any language there are sounds that convey concepts. Sometimes an idea or concept is difficult to put into words but that may be due to a limited vocabulary. Best thing I can suggest for the individual is to improve vocabulary to improve understanding and thinking. Having said that I do believe that the structure of language does have an impact and can provide a different angle to view things from.

Interesting side note--I'm not sure everyone utilizes their own language to its capacity. I wonder how many words there are in English that almost nobody uses. It's possible our inability in certain topics are because we've forgotten the language around those topics. English tends to push us toward metaphor, which could be a limitation of the language or inadequate use of the language. Is that the same for all languages (rhetorical)?

4

I don't know that one language can really capture all dimensions of thinking. I think the best option would be to learn a few different languages from different language families (don't just learn romance languages).

I found that when I learned Spanish, I was able to think about things differently. I think just understanding grammar and language is helpful in its own right in thinking about things.

I wouldn't be surprised if there were some lost or holy language that was able to maximize our brain capacity.

I was kind of thinking the same idea, the language that has more words for different ideas would lend itself to better thinking.

Doesn't the ancient Greek have 9 words for love? It kind of makes English sound dumb.

@DaddyBob, I know my words really break down when I start trying to talk about emotion, love, connection, being vulnerable. I think there's some merit to the assertion. I don't know if there is a single best language for dealing with all topics, or if there is a best language for a particular topic. Really fascinating idea.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:32901
Slug does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.