idw.community
1 3

How seriously do you take Marxism?  I just finished watching Jordan Peterson's Critique of the Communist Manifesto for the second time.

My critique of Marxism is much different than Peterson's because I approach it from the point of view of understanding Marx.  What many critics of Marx seem to ignore is that not much of what is in the Communist Manifesto is actually original.  It is just a rehashing of ideas that had widely circulated before and after the French Revolution.  If you want to understand those ideas it's better to go to original sources than through Marx's rehashing of them.  The failure of the French Revolution should have been enough to dissuade anyone of the validity of those ideas.   So why less than a hundred years later did Marx become the most widely accepted proponent of communism?
   
What seems to have happened is that as peasants became workers a new ready made group of disaffected potential revolutionaries developed.  The fact that workers were concentrated in cities under appalling conditions of overcrowding made planning and executing revolution much easier than with scattered peasants.   Peasants that Marx mostly ignored.   Now we see the same phenomenon as workers are being ignored by Marxists in favor of other disaffected groups that are easier to turn into revolutionaries.

The point I'm making is that there is considerable evidence that Marxism was never about establishing a system but primarily motivated by the desire for revolution.  Therefore the primary critique has to identify the appeal of revolution and what in Marx's personality made revolution appealing to him.  By extension then what makes revolution appealing to his accolades.  It can't be a coincidence that the current crop seem to be upper middle class parasites like Marx.

Peterson must be aware of the point I'm making because he seems keenly aware of the human potential to desire destruction. Why does he gloss over this aspect?

wolfhnd 8 Apr 18
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Be part of the movement!

Welcome to the community for those who value free speech, evidence and civil discourse.

Create your free account

1 comment

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

It seems like the whole point of marxism is just to fight and struggle. Even if they win a battle, they will either turn on each other or look for another battle. They don't want solutions, they don't want any sort of peace - their utopia is just an excuse to keep fighting because it's always going to be out of grasp.

Tom81 Level 7 Apr 18, 2021

There are two types of people that want to burn it all down. The psychopath that Peterson has said hates existence itself and the narcissist who hates the restraints of civilization. Marxists fall into the latter group.

Recent Visitors 18

Photos 4,164 More

Posted by Daveclark5Are strong-minded black people leaving the democrat plantation?

Posted by FOTD13Had a little fun with one of my favorite paintings. Enjoy! Can you spot all the players?

Posted by GeeMacIs Joe Biden becoming less and less capable of handling questions from the press?

Posted by Daveclark5[nih.gov] - What they don’t tell you is that the mRNA vaccines override the natural immune response.

Posted by Mali222My art if it good like it .

Posted by Mali222My art if it good like it .

Posted by 2perosThe donkey told the tiger, "The grass is blue.

Posted by 2perosNothing New…

Posted by 2perosSeems Legit

Posted by 2perosThey Really Get Around!

Posted by Weltansicht Big Pharma and mainstream media are largely owned by two asset management firms: BlackRock and Vanguard.

Posted by JohnHoukMilley Treason SUMMARY: … When I was a kid the name “Benedict Arnold” was the same as Judas Iscariot.

Posted by TragicDogVideoCalifornia Governor Gavin Newsom's thank you card

Posted by TragicDogVideoIs the Left's revisionism finally being starved out?

Posted by WeltansichtTop shareholders in Pfizer stock as of June 2021 Blackrock is @2 with 407 million shares; Blackrock also owns 156 million shares in Facebook AND Blackrock owns 191 million shares in Johnson & ...

Posted by GeeMacRemember the Russia conspiracy, designed to bring down Donald Trump.

  • Top tags#video #youtube #world #government #media #biden #democrats #truth #Police #society #money #reason #god #USA #children #culture #Canada #hope #rights #China #racist #vote #freedom #politics #death #evil #communist #TheTruth #hell #conservative #justice #evidence #antifa #kids #democrat #liberal #racism #laws #socialist #community #violence #Socialism #book #fear #nation #federal #climate #politicians #crime #religion ...

    Members 8,900Top

    Moderators